{
  "pull_request": 119,
  "reviewed_head": "4f2ea071a78da77a84e1de0f5551ec5f71f6ceec",
  "source_sha256": "6f0e1a109ece2679f8ee1e0527cd98abc6a58e664d11fc6033740765ba4a990f",
  "source_bytes": 10883,
  "recommendation": "leave unmerged",
  "blockers": [
    "Fresh initial qualification set passed only 1/3; runs 2 and 3 fail the canonical later warm-up watchdog after seven saved timed calls. Required 3/3 complete accuracy, timing and energy qualifications was not achieved."
  ],
  "qualification": {
    "passed_runs": 1,
    "required_runs": 3,
    "median_ranked_ms": null,
    "median_energy_mj": null,
    "aggregate_observed_mnist_error_pct": 1.7825,
    "observed_mnist_correct": 235722,
    "observed_mnist_total": 240000,
    "aggregate_scope": "Only saved observed MNIST calls, including partial failed runs; descriptive accuracy, never qualification of incomplete runs. Each full run must independently qualify.",
    "saved_timed_calls": 29,
    "complete_passed_runs": 1,
    "no_retries_or_replacement_runs": true
  },
  "runs": [
    {
      "run": 1,
      "passed": true,
      "saved_calls": 15,
      "saved_mnist_calls": 11,
      "saved_holdout_calls": 4,
      "ranked_ms": 2571.362149325284,
      "energy_mj": 517731.0214702567,
      "qualified_mnist_error_pct": 1.788181818181818,
      "observed_mnist_error_pct": 1.788181818181818,
      "mnist_correct": 108033,
      "mnist_total": 110000,
      "canonical_judge_applicable": true,
      "canonical_judge_skip_reason": null,
      "failure_strings": [],
      "warmup_watchdog_bound_ms": null
    },
    {
      "run": 2,
      "passed": false,
      "saved_calls": 7,
      "saved_mnist_calls": 7,
      "saved_holdout_calls": 0,
      "ranked_ms": null,
      "energy_mj": null,
      "qualified_mnist_error_pct": null,
      "observed_mnist_error_pct": 1.7914285714285714,
      "mnist_correct": 68746,
      "mnist_total": 70000,
      "canonical_judge_applicable": false,
      "canonical_judge_skip_reason": "Saved 7 timed calls (7 MNIST and 0 holdout); canonical qualification requires all 15 calls (11 MNIST and 4 holdout). Partial counts cannot be judged as a qualification run.",
      "failure_strings": [
        "timed out while running the method on the untimed warm-up on a kmnist draw"
      ],
      "warmup_watchdog_bound_ms": 90000
    },
    {
      "run": 3,
      "passed": false,
      "saved_calls": 7,
      "saved_mnist_calls": 6,
      "saved_holdout_calls": 1,
      "ranked_ms": null,
      "energy_mj": null,
      "qualified_mnist_error_pct": null,
      "observed_mnist_error_pct": 1.7616666666666667,
      "mnist_correct": 58943,
      "mnist_total": 60000,
      "canonical_judge_applicable": false,
      "canonical_judge_skip_reason": "Saved 7 timed calls (6 MNIST and 1 holdout); canonical qualification requires all 15 calls (11 MNIST and 4 holdout). Partial counts cannot be judged as a qualification run.",
      "failure_strings": [
        "timed out while running the method on the untimed warm-up on a fashion draw"
      ],
      "warmup_watchdog_bound_ms": 90000
    }
  ],
  "source_audit": "No static compliance, input-integrity, persistence or query-truth blockers. Source gate and all head/source/scorer/runner identities are exact. Source is a credited PR #118 derivative; full shared query pools and refresh cadence are documented.",
  "failure_classification": "Observed canonical learner warm-up watchdog failures, not an accuracy disqualification. Modal completed normally and returned all three records; no controller/setup exception occurred. The underlying reason for the two later warm-up stalls was not determined and no retry was performed.",
  "author_primary_audit": "Original author records independently reconstruct 3/3, median 2580.8455810546875 ms and 536878.610466496 mJ; these remain separate and do not replace fresh reviewer failures.",
  "separate_comparison_audit": "2500-step every-400 variant independently reconstructs 3/3 from saved author records; no additional reviewer GPU work performed for secondary variants.",
  "failed_candidate_retention": "Earlier once2000 candidate and all raw records retained. Independently 2/3, failure by 60 labels; no qualifying median or successful-run pooling.",
  "evidence_directory": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119",
  "modal_app": {
    "app_id": "ap-H8mjD2VeGrqn9hJBL1MOfh",
    "state": "stopped",
    "tasks": 0,
    "created_at": "2026-10-12T16:51:41-07:00",
    "stopped_at": "2026-10-12T17:05:24-07:00",
    "verification_scope": "Controller exited 1 after preserving all three learner outcomes; modal app list --json confirms ephemeral app automatically stopped with zero tasks. No unrelated app stopped."
  },
  "completed_at": "2026-10-13T00:07:03.003564+00:00"
}
