{
  "pull_request": 119,
  "reviewed_head": "4f2ea071a78da77a84e1de0f5551ec5f71f6ceec",
  "source_sha256": "6f0e1a109ece2679f8ee1e0527cd98abc6a58e664d11fc6033740765ba4a990f",
  "scorer_sha256": "1bc6d8d96a776565bc70f3ccdb91be7de57187d4495b2b0437fac98f5e120064",
  "runner_sha256": "1180b843cf6c32414774da90c835a8b7298d2db8719989237a793ca1c62a10ab",
  "scope": "Read-only diagnosis of existing saved raw records, controller stdout, learner source and unchanged canonical harness. No GPU reruns, learner/harness changes, PR edits or public posts.",
  "conclusion": "Two warm-up timeouts are proven. The initial fresh maintainer reproduction passed 1/3, with no qualifying three-run median, while the author's separate original canonical batch passed 3/3. Every scoring worker has private fresh model-compilation caches; the first receives 180 seconds while later equally fresh workers receive 90 seconds. That policy asymmetry is real, but existing records cannot identify the stalled phase or prove a systematic harness bug or transient infrastructure fault.",
  "proven": {
    "fresh_workers_and_caches": "Every timed_call constructs a new Worker. Worker._start creates a unique private temporary directory and initializes HOME, TMPDIR, XDG_CACHE_HOME, TRITON_CACHE_DIR, TORCHINDUCTOR_CACHE_DIR, TORCH_EXTENSIONS_DIR and CUDA_CACHE_PATH inside it. Worker.close kills the process group, reap_sandbox removes sandbox-user files/processes, and the private worker directory is removed. The learner setdefault cache paths do not override these already-set environment values. Therefore the learner compiled-code disk caches do not persist between canonical workers; CUDA graphs/module _S also cannot survive a worker exit.",
    "cache_scope_limit": "The statement concerns the harness-controlled per-worker caches and learner state. It does not measure internal driver/system caches, packaged library kernels or host scheduling.",
    "budgets": "First scoring-call warm-up gets 180000 ms. Calls 2 through 15 get 90000 ms, even though each is a newly created worker. The energy worker also has private fresh caches and gets 90000 ms. Both failed runs completed seven timed calls and failed during the next fresh worker warm-up, so their applicable bound was 90000 ms.",
    "wall_clock_start": "Worker.call first completes separate garbage collection and stages the current input arrays into shared mmap. It then invokes Worker.request(cmd=go). That function starts deadline=time.monotonic()+timeout_s immediately before serializing/writing the request and waiting for the response. The parent mmap copies are outside this request deadline, although inside parent_ms for a successful call.",
    "wall_clock_includes": "Request header/pipe transmission and reply collection; worker-side input copies to GPU, synchronization and L2 flush; the entire first classify invocation; setup of models/optimizer/schedules, current tangent computation/reset, torch.compile callable creation and first compiled loss/backward/update executions, autotuning/optimizer-state creation and CUDA graph capture, reset followed by all 2000 training updates and pseudo-label refresh/readout; final synchronization, output validation/CPU labels and reply. There is no narrower compile-only or train-only watchdog.",
    "wall_clock_excludes": "Worker process creation and hello/start, protocol calibration, module import/load, the separate GC request and parent staging happen before this warm-up request. Process/start, import and GC have their own separate watchdogs. The 90-second failure is not one of those stages.",
    "ranked_time_scope": "The approximately 2.5-second ranked results come from the subsequent timed classify call after the same worker already completed its warm-up and holds compiled callables/CUDA graphs. The timed call reloads inputs and refits from scratch, but amortizes that worker's initial compilation/capture. It does not report first-call warm-up duration.",
    "failure_records": [
      {
        "run": 1,
        "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/reviewer-modal/run-1.json",
        "sha256": "248a0729a9bfe2a9d4a4caa4cd01474075438b4cee69e1ede3cd65c305eb6559",
        "returncode": 0,
        "saved_calls": 15,
        "record_problems": [],
        "stderr_empty": true,
        "ranked_ms": 2571.362149325284,
        "energy_mj": 517731.0214702567,
        "warmup_latencies_saved": false,
        "phase_trace_saved": false
      },
      {
        "run": 2,
        "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/reviewer-modal/run-2.json",
        "sha256": "6cd8354b4f5ffdd0d54ade69b83a42004b9e257ffa78f9976e11eb59000271fc",
        "returncode": 1,
        "saved_calls": 7,
        "record_problems": [
          "timed out while running the method on the untimed warm-up on a kmnist draw"
        ],
        "stderr_empty": true,
        "ranked_ms": null,
        "energy_mj": null,
        "warmup_latencies_saved": false,
        "phase_trace_saved": false
      },
      {
        "run": 3,
        "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/reviewer-modal/run-3.json",
        "sha256": "3e8f2a02f50c4f5e2c2a0b58811d4fecf218ff5b010bbe713bf84c0fba961de1",
        "returncode": 1,
        "saved_calls": 7,
        "record_problems": [
          "timed out while running the method on the untimed warm-up on a fashion draw"
        ],
        "stderr_empty": true,
        "ranked_ms": null,
        "energy_mj": null,
        "warmup_latencies_saved": false,
        "phase_trace_saved": false
      }
    ],
    "logging_limit": "All three saved outer stderr strings are empty. Controller stdout repeats scorer call summaries and the two generic deadline failures, with no compile/capture/tangent/training phase markers or CPU/GPU load traces. The failed warm-up produces no success reply, and its duration/phase is not stored in the Call list. Worker.close kills the stalled process, so its live stack is unavailable from saved files.",
    "protocol_correction": "Earlier progress narration incorrectly suggested compiled kernels could hit caches across canonical workers. That explanation is corrected here: cache reuse is within each worker from foreign warm-up to timed fit, not across scoring workers."
  },
  "comparison_pr118": {
    "reviewed_head": "436b80bb40e4c346792ddad71670c7a5dbc8c5e9",
    "source_sha256": "a3b18bac64dddc3f7aa8c614e2279932aa74040720cb861e8dfa40eaa67923c3",
    "same_scorer_sha256": true,
    "fresh_pass_count": 3,
    "source_delta": {
      "upstream118_head": "436b80bb40e4c346792ddad71670c7a5dbc8c5e9",
      "upstream118_sha256": "a3b18bac64dddc3f7aa8c614e2279932aa74040720cb861e8dfa40eaa67923c3",
      "ast_unchanged_functions": [
        "_capture",
        "_cross_teach",
        "_forward",
        "_load",
        "_loss",
        "_orth",
        "_readout",
        "_step",
        "_tangents",
        "_update",
        "classify"
      ],
      "ast_changed_functions": [
        "_build",
        "_reset"
      ],
      "removed_functions": [],
      "added_functions": []
    },
    "capture_and_compilation_structure": "_capture, _step, classify, _load, loss/backward/update/readout functions are AST-identical; both use torch.compile(fullgraph=True,dynamic=False) and fresh CUDA graphs per worker. PR119 changes steps 2500 to 2000, refresh cadence 200 to 400, and query sampling pools from disjoint halves to all queries. Compiled loss input shapes remain the same; the schedule/decay lengths and eager pool shapes change. No cache-lifetime or watchdog change exists between these submissions.",
    "interpretation": "PR118's complete three-run reproduction and PR119's one complete reviewer run plus three complete author runs show that the protocol can complete this learner family and PR119 can complete 15 calls. They do not locate the two failures, establish identical host conditions, or prove why the eighth warm-up stalled."
  },
  "inferences_and_limits": [
    {
      "claim": "Cold compilation/capture or host scheduling variation is a plausible contributor.",
      "status": "Inference, not proven. Both happen inside the watchdog and caches are fresh, but no phase timings or stacks survive."
    },
    {
      "claim": "A first-versus-later warm-up budget that assumes cached compilation would be inconsistent with worker isolation.",
      "status": "Conditional design concern. The asymmetric budgets are proven; the intended policy rationale is not established here. The observed failures still violate the released canonical bound."
    },
    {
      "claim": "The two failures after seven successful calls establish a deterministic eighth-call harness bug.",
      "status": "Not established. They are in separate containers and different foreign datasets, with no retained cross-call learner state; PR119 run1 completed all15. A systematic resource/cleanup issue could only be assessed with new diagnostic traces."
    },
    {
      "claim": "A transient Modal infrastructure failure caused these results.",
      "status": "Not observed. The controller completed normally and all records returned; no host resource, throttling, memory, compiler stack or scheduling telemetry was retained. Normal controller completion does not rule out host variability."
    },
    {
      "claim": "The partial saved accuracy proves D5 qualification.",
      "status": "False. Incomplete records cannot reconstruct canonical judge or energy results and cannot replace the two failed outcomes."
    }
  ],
  "next_diagnostic_step": "If separately authorized, collect phase timestamps and stack/host-resource snapshots during an instrumented diagnostic worker while preserving the exact learner bytes and original failed records. Such an instrumented scorer has a different hash and is diagnostic evidence, not replacement canonical qualification. Any change to the canonical warm-up policy should be explicit, versioned and applied consistently to affected entrants rather than silently extending only this candidate's bound.",
  "evidence_references": {
    "budget": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 127
    },
    "budget_selection": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 286
    },
    "fresh_worker_per_call": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 317
    },
    "import_before_warmup": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 326
    },
    "warmup_request": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 330
    },
    "new_worker_and_private_caches": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1000
    },
    "cache_environment": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1003
    },
    "watchdog_deadline_start": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1074
    },
    "parent_staging_before_watchdog": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1101
    },
    "go_request_after_staging": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1106
    },
    "kill_and_reap_worker": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1115
    },
    "remove_cache_directory": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1142
    },
    "worker_input_staging_and_classify": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/canonical/mnist.py",
      "line": 1599
    },
    "compile_callables": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/author/submission.py",
      "line": 196
    },
    "compile_autotune_graph_capture": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/author/submission.py",
      "line": 200
    },
    "first_call_setup": {
      "path": "/Users/yaroslavvb/git/sutro-problems/output/pr-review-20261012/pr119/author/submission.py",
      "line": 221
    }
  },
  "written_at": "2026-10-13T01:38:11.735722+00:00",
  "published_rule_boundary": "This diagnosis does not claim an additional three successful maintainer runs are explicitly required by the published submission rules. It reports the extra reproduction actually performed and its unresolved failures. Author canonical records remain valid separately and were not replaced or discarded."
}
